Worth a shout?
Dr. Matt long encourages middle distance coaches to consider their spatial location and potential to make verbal intervention during competition.
Adjacent to p.215 within Sebastian Coe's autobiography Running My Life, is an iconic image of father and coach, Peter, kneeling at the side of a Zurich track. The date is 19th August 1981 and Seb is on his way to a new world mile record (3m 48.53s) at the Weltklasse. Coe senior has hands cupped to mouth with his son recalling that he was, "cheered on by my father yelling out split times". The image of the bespectacled Peter Coe in trade mark red jacket encapsulates the significance of both spatial location of the coach and potential to make verbal intervention during competition.
Plenty has been written about good practice with regard to the way coaches offer 'terminal feedback' to athletes after training session or competition. Less has been researched in relation to 'concurrent feedback' (Galligan et al. 2000) which coaches can choose to give during competition itself. Davis et al. (2000) term this 'exteroceptive feedback' because it is ordinarily underpinned by coaching observation. Jowett et al. (2007) have stressed the importance of building an effective coach-athlete relationship and this article explores this dynamic in a middle distance competition context.
Focussed interviews with a sample of 11 well established middle distances coaches and mentors were conducted to explore:
Some in the sample took a non-interventionist stance. BMC President Norman Poole, for instance, argued that athletes, "have to learn to handle situations themselves". This position was endorsed by Birchfield Harriers coach Phil Sargeant who argued athletes in the proverbial 'zone', "may not want to hear voices of their coaches", blocking them out as they would any other spectator. A strong advocate of planning prior to and debriefing after races, Poole likened his athletes to pugilists by using the boxing analogy of proverbially being "on your own in the ring" during the heat of competition. He was convinced that athletes who learn their "racing craft" through self-sufficiency can handle even world class competition at a young chronological age. The best practice example of Steve Cram was offered who took the 1983 world 1,500m title aged just 22 years. BMC Academy Director David Lowes echoed these sentiments by stating that, "The need for 'encouragement' from the coach, although good, should not be expected. Athletes need to train to 'encourage' themselves inwardly without expecting outside cues" (See Lowes, 2013).
In advocating the cautious use of intervention, Horwill scholarship winner Jamie French felt that "coach led feedback can raise awareness of external factors that the athlete was unaware of". With specific reference to 800m running, England Athletics (Midlands Area Endurance Coach Mentor) Geoff James said, "I position myself at the 600m point as it's the critical point in the race". He continued that, "I question the value of coaches locating themselves in the home straight. It's just too late to make a verbal intervention on the 2nd lap after athletes have begun to kick for home". Significantly James chooses to make 'paratelic' (process) based interventions rather than 'telic' (goal) based ones (Smith and Apter, 1975). With specific reference to his work with a BUCS medallist he continued, "I tend to give one command only. I may shout 'hands' to denote that she keeps placing her thumbs on her fingers as she begins to tire or 'head position' to try and avoid her shoulders tensing". An endorsement of this process based intervention philosophy was offered by Birchfield coach and team manager Dave Lawrence who stressed the important of coach 'knowledgeability' of the athlete. "You must observe what your athlete tends to do wrong in training and then make a decision about what one thing you are going to try and prevent them from doing at a critical point in the race". Lawrence pointed out that the coach simply cannot attend all of the athlete's races in the course of a season let alone their career and that an 'over-dependency' of athlete on the coach was unhealthy.
This above links to a wider debate about 'overcoaching' (Goldsmith, 2012), which was alluded to by Jenny Harris (National Coach Mentor Youth Endurance). She forewarned, "You can overcomplicate the mind of the young athlete by giving them information overload. I believe the athlete's body doesn't learn to respond when coaches overly intervene in the heat of battle in a race". Perceptively she noted that, "If you are going to intervene during a race there should be no set place. One needs to be athlete focused". Like James, she utilises command based words such as 'push' or 'pick your pace up' in order to avoid information overload. This point about overload was reiterated by National Coach Mentor Neville Taylor who commented that, "The trick is not to say too much. You should have dealt with the technical side of things in training". The man who coached Wendy Sly to a Los Angeles Olympic 3,000m silver in 1984 added that, "Never be critical with an athlete during a race. If I'm within earshot down the back straight and my athlete is stuck on the kerb, I may shout 'Get out now'". The point made by Harris about an athlete-centred approach was also emphasised by Shaftesbury Barnet coach Nadeem Shaikh, who spoke of "needing to know the individual as well as the athlete", reminding us that athletes are diverse and learn in different ways.
Former UKA National Trainer Jeremy Harries, who once guided the careers of John Nuttall and Helen Clitheroe confirmed that he always chose to locate himself between the 300m and 200m point whether it be an 800m or 1,500 involving his athlete(s). "I could view the race unfolding better from the vantage point of the back straight away from a crowded home straight". This was a deliberate strategy, "in order to give both my athlete and myself breathing space after the race. They have time to gather their thoughts and to reflect whilst walking over to the back straight and so do you". Significantly Harries indicated that he utilised both 'process' and 'goal' based interventions. An example of the latter may be the call to said athlete that "X is 15 metres behind and closing in on you winning this race".
'Goal' based interventions were referred to by City of Stoke AC coach Alan Morris, who has guided GB 800m athlete Emma Jackson to a 4th placing in the Delhi Commonwealth Games and a Daegu world championship semi final. In echoing the sentiments of David Lowes, Morris commented that, "It depends on the level of athlete you are dealing with. Experienced athletes tend not to need interventions". For teenage athletes Morris will adopt an entirely different approach compared to trackside interventions made with the aforementioned Jackson. "I tend to shout 'come on keep it up' in the middle of the race or 'finish it off' as they began their final sprint to the finish".
Poole and Sargeant's points about abstaining from intervention are paramount when one considers that many championship events from English schools upwards make effective verbal intervention in noisy environments almost impossible. In a similar vein comments made by Lowes remind us that the type of coaching intervention made may be dependent on the level of emotional maturation of the athlete. (See Long and French, 2013). James' point about coaches who locate themselves in the home straight raises the issue of whether by doing so they are performing the role of coach or have 'gone native' as spectator. Jenny Harris' point about information overload reminds us that middle distance athletes can't process intrinsic questions at the pace they are running and with that level of physical exertion. Jeremy Harries' comments indicate that athlete-centred coaching interventions can involve both process and goal thus attempting to effect a reversal between 'paratelic' and 'telic' psychological states. His point about both athlete and coach needing their proverbial and literal 'space' in the immediate aftermath of competition is pertinent if said athlete has underperformed. It gives the coach time for composure and rational thought. This is congruent with Deci et al's (1999) finding that positive performance feedback enhances future intrinsic motivation of the athlete. This famously didn't occur when a tearful Paula Radcliffe and husband and coach Gary Lough were involved in an altercation moments after she had stepped off the Edmonton track after missing out on a medal at the 2001 world championships.
Comments by Morris remind us we need to consider the developmental age of athletes in terms of their emotional, social and psychological maturation, as much as biological age and physiological development. His point about non intervention for the mature athlete along with Harris' concerns about the dangers of over-intervention, are important reminders that the coach should be attempting to responsibilise the athlete. This is supported by the notion of 'Autonomy Support' provided by Cognitive evaluation theorists in emphasising that athletes are, "individuals deserving self-determination, and not mere pawns that should be controlled to obtain a certain outcome" (Mageau et al. 2003). Shaikh offers us massive insight in that only some athletes will learn from verbal intervention. These aural learners will respond to hearing voices but taking into considering Fleming's (2005) VARK model, we know that other athletes learn best for instance through images or simply doing things.
What Neville Taylor gives us is a perspective on both the need for unconditional positive regard and the ability to make tactical interventions. Dave Lawrence's comments encourage coaches to think about developing an unconscious competence in transferring good practice from a training to a racing context.
If you quote information from this page in your work then the reference for this page is:
The information on this page is adapted from Long (2013) with the kind permission of the author and the editor of the BMC News.
About the Author
Dr. Matt Long is a British Athletics Coach Education Tutor and volunteer coach with Birmingham University AC.
The following Sports Coach pages provide additional information on this topic: